1889 Quarter Error List with Pictures

Mirrorlike backgrounds can draw attention away from a tiny incomplete edge. On one 1889 collector quarter, that minor clip accompanied an auction sold price of $1,800 in July 2015.

The documented example in this 1889 quarter errors guide is a Proof, a coin specially made for collectors. Comparable genuine pieces have an estimated whole-coin range of $1,200–$3,500.

Look around the edge with the checks below, then consider the clip alongside the condition of the reflective surfaces.

1889 Liberty Seated Quarter Proof Minor Clip

The auctioned quarter was graded PCGS PR65 Cameo and described as having a minor clip. PR65 is a well-preserved Proof grade; Cameo describes frosted-looking designs against reflective backgrounds.

A clip begins before those attractive surfaces are struck. The metal blank is incomplete when it reaches the stamping tools.

With a very small clip, the outline may remain nearly round. The shortage of metal can be most noticeable where the rim fails to form normally.

This differs from a dent made by dropping a finished coin. Examine the edge as carefully as the polished-looking faces.

Estimated Value

GreatCollections lists the PR65 Cameo example with a sold price of $1,800 on July 5, 2015. That figure belongs to the complete coin, including its collector finish and preservation.

Estimate $1,200–$3,500 for comparable authenticated minor-clip Proofs. Clear contrast and undisturbed reflective surfaces help support the upper part of the range.

The small clip does not account for the entire price. Cleaning lines, haze, or later edge damage can weaken the comparison.

How to Identify

First establish that the coin is a Proof, rather than an ordinary quarter made shiny by polishing. Compare the reflective backgrounds and frosted-looking design with certified photographs of the auctioned example.

Rotate the coin slowly under a lamp and inspect the full circumference through a magnifier. A minor clip may show local rim weakness instead of a deep missing arc.

At the affected area, compare the edge and corresponding parts of both faces. Look for the way the original rim formed around the shortage of metal.

A sharp fold, fresh cut, or pushed-up lip may reveal later damage.

Leave a certified coin in its holder and keep the mirrors untouched. Match the actual edge feature to the documented Proof before treating an isolated rim mark as a clip.

 

Conclusion

The estimated $1,200–$3,500 range reflects an attractive Proof quarter with a minor clip, not the value of a tiny edge defect by itself. The documented auction provides a useful whole-coin comparison.

Inspect the complete rim, compare both faces at the affected area, and preserve the original surfaces. A small blank shortage needs careful edge study even when the coin’s outline still looks almost round.