2019 Quarter Error List with Pictures
A tiny doubled wheel spoke and a quarter missing 27% of its blank need very different comparisons. The park design tells you where to begin.
These 2019 quarter errors carry working estimates of $1–$3,000. PCGS also lists an exceptional $50,000 eBay Best Offer record from March 2021 for an American Memorial discovery coin; that is an indexed offer record, not a standard auction result.
Explore the checks below to separate each park’s real features from damage and ordinary design details.
1. 2019 America the Beautiful Quarter Weak River Detail on San Antonio
The river lines on a San Antonio quarter may look soft while nearby details remain easier to see. A park guide reports this as a weak strike.
During a weak strike, metal does not fully fill the fine design in the stamping tool. Some lines can therefore look incomplete from the start.
Wear and grease blocking the tool can produce similar effects. The remaining surface helps distinguish them.
This report does not establish a test strike or deliberate press adjustment. The feature to examine is the weak river detail itself, together with the rest of the coin.
Estimated Value
For a modest, genuine striking weakness on an ordinary Philadelphia or Denver example, estimate $1–$25. Small differences in sharpness do not usually create a major error premium.
An unworn surface can make the original weakness easier to demonstrate. A circulated coin with broadly flattened high points may simply show normal wear.
West Point and collector issues need their own underlying coin values. The range should not replace a separate assessment of mint, finish, and unusually high condition.
How to Identify
Compare the river lines with a sharp San Antonio quarter under the same light. Then look at the other raised details for wear that could explain the loss.
A 10× magnifier helps separate smooth worn high points from a weakly formed area with its original surface intact. Check whether weakness is local or affects much of both faces.
Photograph the weak river beside neighboring sharp lines, with the whole back visible in another view. Inspect the opposite face for crushing that might show pressure applied after the coin was struck.
If only one small patch is missing, also consider material that blocked the tool. Weak river lines alone do not identify the exact reason the design failed to fill.
2. 2019 America the Beautiful Quarter Broadstrikes
A quarter can become wider while keeping its main design complete. The ring around the blank, called the collar, normally controls how far the metal spreads.
If the blank is struck outside that restraint, the result is a broadstrike. Its outer border may be wider or less evenly rounded.
Park-specific guides report broadstrikes for Lowell and Philadelphia War in the Pacific quarters. Each design needs its own example and edge view.
A wide rim alone does not settle the question. A shifted design with part missing beyond the metal belongs to a different kind of striking problem.
Estimated Value
For an authenticated ordinary clad broadstrike, use an estimated $25–$300 range. A noticeable spread with full lettering is more appealing than a tiny change in rim width.
Compare condition as well as shape. Smooth original surfaces and a readable date support the stronger end, while scratches and flattening reduce appeal.
The Lowell and War in the Pacific reports do not establish identical dimensions. A more dramatic coin should be valued from its actual spread rather than the park name alone.
How to Identify
Measure a loose candidate at several angles with calipers before deciding that it is oversized. Compare the results with the normal 24.26 mm diameter and check its weight against 5.67 grams on a scale.
Inspect every outer letter and both complete designs beside a normal example of the same park. The absence of a blank crescent opposite cut-off design helps distinguish broadstriking from an off-center strike.
With a 10× magnifier, examine the rim, edge grooves, and the transition into the wider border. Later hammering crushes completed detail, so look for design formed naturally as the metal spread rather than flattened by a later blow.
3. 2019 America the Beautiful Quarter Cracked and Chipped Dies
Small lumps can appear when steel breaks from the tool that stamps a coin. A narrow crack in that tool leaves a raised line instead.
Lowell reports include an ear lump and cracks near the tower or worker’s arm. San Antonio examples have marks at the cross, arcade, or wheat.
River of No Return chips can resemble birds in trees or appear by the boatman’s hat. Those shapes are not extra artwork.
War in the Pacific reports include front neck or QUARTER marks and separate S-mint back chips. Larger rim-connected breaks are called cuds and need an actual rim connection.
Estimated Value
Estimate $2–$50 for small, recognizable chips or cracks on ordinary examples. Larger breaks, including a clear rim-connected cud, can fit a broader $25–$300 range.
The nickname “bird in the tree” does not by itself determine a River coin’s price. Size, visibility, and surface quality matter more.
Some Pacific reports combine a rim break with an off-center strike. Compare the complete coin with a similar compound example rather than adding two full error prices together.
How to Identify
Read the park name and mint letter before picking a comparison photograph. Similar-looking bumps can occur in different parts of these designs.
Keep the suspected mark and a nearby letter together in one close-up. Check around its base for glue, dirt, or pushed-up metal beside a dent.
Now use a 10× magnifier under moving light to distinguish a raised ridge from a scratch. The ridge comes from an opening in the steel tool; a scratch cuts finished metal.
Lowell’s ear and tower lumps are interior features. A cud candidate must actually connect to the rim, including on a River coin near trees or rocks.
For Pacific examples, inspect QUARTER on Washington’s side. The reported S-mint palm-tree and equipment marks belong to separate back specimens.
4. 2019 America the Beautiful Quarter Doubled Designs
A repeated outline can originate in the steel stamping tool, called a doubled die. Its position differs among the five park designs.
Philadelphia American Memorial and San Antonio examples affect front lettering. San Antonio also has back doubling at the cross’s lower-right meeting point.
Lowell’s Philadelphia variety affects a wheel spoke near the worker’s arm. Philadelphia Pacific doubling appears on the larger soldier’s backpack, while Denver River examples affect trees beside the bow.
S-mint Pacific lettering is separately reported. It needs its own metal, finish, and design comparison rather than the Philadelphia backpack photograph.
Estimated Value
For ordinary matched doubled-design examples, estimate $5–$300, depending on clarity and condition. Subtle extra detail should not be priced like a celebrated discovery coin.
PCGS indexes $50,000 for an American Memorial discovery listing in March 2021. Its sale type is eBay Best Offer, and its grade field says NGC Genuine.
That is an exceptional index entry, not a standard auction result or a general doubled-die price. Genuine is not a numerical condition grade.
How to Identify
Check the park and mint before enlarging a suspected doubled feature. American Memorial’s Philadelphia front includes IN GOD WE TRUST, OF AMERICA, and RTY in LIBERTY; San Antonio’s includes LIBERTY and the motto.
On Lowell, inspect outside the spoke nearest the worker’s arm with a 10× magnifier. For San Antonio’s back, examine the cross’s lower-right meeting point rather than the bell or arcade.
The River trees to inspect are the first left of the bow and the upper-left part of the first tall tree to its right. Pacific’s Philadelphia feature is above the larger soldier’s backpack.
For an S coin, establish the finish before choosing a comparison. A specially made silver Proof has different surfaces from an ordinary clad coin, though either can show an extra design outline.
Compare repeated outlines with the matching photographs, excluding flat shelves from striking movement and detail spread by worn tools.
5. 2019 America the Beautiful Quarter Off-Center Strikes
A San Antonio report describes the central cross shifted left with extra blank space at the right. It calls the displacement about 5%.
To qualify as an off-center strike, both faces must show the blank entering the press out of position. A one-face shift may instead come from a misaligned stamping tool.
Lowell and War in the Pacific guides also report off-center examples. Some Pacific reports include a rim break on the same coin.
The missing design and untouched crescent are the useful features. Neither the park name nor an uneven border alone proves this error.
Estimated Value
An estimated $40–$1,500 range covers genuine dated off-center examples, from small shifts to more dramatic, attractive coins. The reported San Antonio 5% displacement belongs toward the modest end.
A larger shift is more visible, but a lost date or badly damaged surface can reduce appeal. Both the park and mint should remain identifiable.
A Pacific coin with an accompanying rim break needs a whole-coin comparison. The same object should not receive two separate complete valuations for its combined features.
How to Identify
Photograph both faces without cropping out the edge. Place them beside a normal quarter of the same park and find where the design runs beyond the available metal.
For San Antonio, the reported cross shift on the back needs a corresponding change on the front. If Washington stays normally centered, inspect the coin as a possible one-tool misalignment instead.
Use a 10× magnifier to trace the boundary between struck and blank metal. A filed edge removes metal rather than leaving an untouched crescent.
A loose clad example may still weigh near 5.67 grams. Check that with a scale, compare an intact span with 24.26 mm using calipers, and inspect its edge grooves for trimming.
6. 2019 America the Beautiful Quarter Struck Through Material
An object between a blank and a stamping tool can leave a depression or stop part of the design from forming. This is a struck-through error.
Lowell reports include a West Point coin with a small hair-area interruption and another appearance nicknamed “Angel Wing.” They should be compared as separate examples.
A Philadelphia American Memorial report describes interrupted detail at the back date and the woman’s forearm. The material that caused it is not identified.
A Pacific candidate needs the same physical examination. A copper-colored or weak patch alone can also come from stains, dirt, or later damage.
Estimated Value
Use an estimated $25–$1,500 range for genuine examples, from small local interruptions to strong, clear impressions on desirable coins. A West Point host can add normal mint-related value.
The Lowell MS67 hair-area report concerns an unworn coin with very few imperfections. It is not automatically the same specimen as the “Angel Wing” example.
A larger depression is not always more valuable. Clear strike evidence and undamaged surrounding design matter more than an unexplained rough patch or attractive nickname.
How to Identify
Photograph the interrupted design before touching the surface, using a 10× magnifier and light from several angles. Follow its boundary to see where clear design stops and the impression begins.
American Memorial’s back date and the woman’s forearm need comparison with the same undamaged design. Lowell’s hair-area flaw and wing-like impression require separate photographs.
Neither shape identifies the trapped material by itself. A fresh scrape may cut completed letters and leave raised metal along its edges.
On Pacific candidates, look for an actual depression rather than color alone. Loose dirt and stains can hide details without changing the way they were struck.
Keep any attached material in place. Removing it can destroy useful evidence of how the surface formed.
7. 2019 America the Beautiful Quarter Clipped and Incomplete Blanks
A large part of the American Memorial example’s blank was missing before it received the design. Mint Error News describes the clip as 27% and the coin as PCGS MS64.
That grade means unworn with some marks. The missing metal, rather than a shifted strike, creates its unusual outline.
A separate River of No Return example has an oval incomplete blank, called an elliptical clip, and is listed as NGC MS62. Lowell guides also report clipped blanks.
These are different shapes within the missing-blank category. A later cut through a finished quarter needs to be ruled out on each coin.
Estimated Value
For genuine ordinary-size quarters with clipped or incomplete blanks, estimate $100–$2,000. Small clips on common worn examples tend toward the lower end; dramatic original outlines can bring more.
The 27% American Memorial coin and oval River example offer different visual comparisons. Their mint letters should not be guessed from the page on which a photograph appears.
A complete date and clearly recognizable park help identify the coin. Fresh cuts, smoothing, or damage at the gap lower its appeal.
How to Identify
Weigh a loose candidate and record the complete outline before judging the percentage missing. A normal clad quarter is 5.67 grams and 24.26 mm, checked with a scale and calipers.
Use a 10× magnifier at each end of a gap to inspect original metal flow and any fresh tool tracks. A weak rim opposite a clip can help, but is not required in every case.
For the oval River example, follow the entire perimeter rather than looking for one curved bite. Compare it with the published error photographs and inspect edge grooves where they survive.
A smooth cut alone proves little. Both the design and the edge must support metal missing before the strike.
8. 2019 America the Beautiful Quarter Missing Outer Clad Layer
A normal circulation quarter has pale copper-nickel outer layers over a copper core. If an outer layer is missing, the copper can receive the design directly.
War in the Pacific reports include copper exposure on a face or near the lower back motto. San Antonio reports describe exposed copper around Washington’s hair tie or across a larger area.
Each coin needs its own layer and weight checks. Brown color can also come from staining or chemical damage.
This explanation applies to clad quarters. The 2019 silver Proof, a specially prepared collector coin, does not have the same copper-core construction.
Estimated Value
An estimated $100–$2,000 range suits authenticated missing-layer examples, allowing for the amount exposed and the coin’s preservation. A large original copper face can be easier to display than a small, unclear patch.
Partial loss and a whole missing face need different comparisons. Both should retain evidence that the exposed metal received the strike.
For a condition comparison, scratches or corrosion may greatly reduce appeal. A brown quarter with its outer layer still intact should not receive this error price.
How to Identify
Identify the metal first: ordinary clad quarters have a copper core, but S silver Proofs contain 99.9% silver and weigh about 6.343 grams. The silver collector coin cannot lose an outer copper-nickel layer it never had.
For a loose clad candidate, use a scale and calipers to compare with 5.67 grams and 24.26 mm. Follow the exposed copper from the grooved edge into the affected face with a 10× magnifier, rather than judging brown color alone.
Look closely at the design over the exposed area to decide whether it formed there naturally. Grinding cuts or flattens finished detail, while staining can change color without removing any layer; each partial loss also needs its own weight assessment.
9. 2019 America the Beautiful Quarter Lowell Double Strike
Two shifted impressions of Washington or the lettering can indicate a coin that received another strike after moving. Collectors call this a double strike.
A year-error list reports a Denver Lowell example with overlapping front detail. The coin needs to show how the two impressions fit together.
This differs from a doubled die, where the extra detail was already in the steel stamping tool. Small flat shelves caused by movement during one strike are another look-alike.
A true second impression should affect a connected set of design features. One thick letter alone does not establish another strike.
Estimated Value
For an authenticated double-struck Lowell quarter, estimate $200–$3,000. The range allows for small overlapping impressions through a dramatic displaced second strike.
A clear relationship between the two designs makes the error easier to explain and display. A readable date and recognizable Lowell back also matter.
This is an estimate for the reported error category, not a completed sale assigned to a certified Denver specimen. Damage, cleaning, or an incomplete year can reduce collector appeal even on a genuine multiple strike.
How to Identify
Draw an imaginary line from one repeated letter to its original position. Do the other repeated details shift in a matching direction?
A second portrait or connected group of letters is stronger evidence than one thick stroke. Inspect the relationship with a 10× magnifier.
Turn to the back and compare its design with the front’s displacement. The two sides may look different, but their strike evidence must still explain the same coin.
A loose normal blank can remain near 5.67 grams after another strike. Check that with a scale and record its actual outline with calipers against the normal 24.26 mm diameter.
Inspect the grooved edge for later tools and the extra impression for sunken copied detail. Pressing finished coins together can create a different, misleading mark.
Conclusion
Working estimates of $1–$3,000 cover the ordinary error examples discussed here. The separate $50,000 Best Offer index entry should not set expectations for every doubled letter.
Keep the park name, mint letter, and both faces in your photographs. Use weight to investigate missing metal and close-up views to judge how the design formed.
A W is a normal 2019 mint mark. The error must be something beyond that letter.