1922 Dollar Coin Error List with Pictures
A 1922-S Peace dollar struck fifteen percent off center brought $32,200 at the 2003 ANA auction. PCGS graded the well-preserved coin MS65.
Other 1922 Peace dollar errors are much subtler: a raised “moustache,” a thin peeling layer, or a stepped edge. Estimated whole-coin values below run from $60–$40,000.
These checks cover ordinary Peace dollars, with separate examples from different mints. Read on to find the feature that matches your coin.
1. 1922 Peace Dollar Faint Designs from Clashing Tools
A faint trace of Liberty’s hair can appear among the eagle-side details when the two stamping tools strike each other. No coin is between them during that accidental contact.
The tools, called dies, can then copy those contact marks onto later dollars. This is a die clash.
Philadelphia reports concern the area right of the leaves and below DOLLAR. A Denver example has a separate feature running between the eagle and the N of UNUM.
The marks must fit the design from the opposite face. A random line or groove nearby is not automatically a clash.
Estimated Value
For a clearly identified clash, estimate $60–$600 for the complete dollar. Slight traces may add little above the value of an ordinary coin in the same condition.
Recognizable transferred design brings more interest than an isolated unexplained line. Compare other Peace-dollar clashes with similar visibility, keeping Philadelphia and Denver patterns separate.
The Denver example can also show tripled leaves. Its total price should not be divided into fixed payments for each feature appearing on the same coin.
How to Identify
Compare the faint back mark with the corresponding part of a normal Liberty portrait, using a transparent image overlay if helpful. A true clash should place an opposing-design fragment where the two tools could contact, rather than create a random new shape.
The Philadelphia discussion concerns areas beside the leaves and below DOLLAR, where the suggested hair trace needs a careful image match. Denver’s eagle-to-UNUM feature must be examined separately, using a confirmed example of that mint’s pattern.
Inspect any extra line for a sunken cut or raised metal pushed out by a later scratch. A recognizable piece of the opposite design, in the matching position, provides better evidence than an isolated line.
2. 1922 Peace Dollar Peeling Surface Metal
One 1922 Philadelphia dollar graded NGC MS64 has a surface that separated along a weak layer. Other auction examples include partially detached metal, fully detached flakes, and a separate San Francisco lamination.
The silver alloy can develop weak areas before striking. Later peeling along one of those areas is called a lamination.
An attached flap and a missing flake are different appearances of that process. Neither automatically means the entire coin split into two halves.
The unaffected design around the flaw helps reveal what happened. A broad scrape can remove metal too, but usually leaves different borders and tool marks.
Estimated Value
The Philadelphia NGC MS64 front-lamination example sold for $192 in July 2021. Estimate $75–$850 for authenticated laminations, depending on the visible separation and the coin’s condition.
A small flake can add only a modest premium, while a large attached piece may be more striking. The estimate includes the underlying silver dollar.
Compare the size and condition of the actual layer boundary. Detached flakes should not be assigned the price of a complete retained-flap error without examining what remains.
How to Identify
Photograph a retained flap beside the design surrounding it. Detail still visible on the flap can connect it with the surface from which it separated.
Leave the attachment untouched. A detached piece cannot show that relationship as clearly once its original position is lost.
Compare the Philadelphia front examples separately from the San Francisco report. One coin’s affected location should not be borrowed for another.
Under side lighting, examine the thin boundary where intact metal meets the loose or missing surface. A gouge may instead have cutting tracks and pushed-up borders.
If a flake has already fallen away, inspect the natural layered opening it left rather than attempting to lift more metal for proof.
3. 1922 Peace Dollar Original Blank Flaws
A coin can receive its design on a metal disc that has an irregular surface. That starting disc is called a blank, and an original flaw can survive the strike.
Two Philadelphia examples were cataloged as struck on defective blanks, one graded ANACS AU55 and another AU58 Details. Their labels do not establish an identical shape.
The relationship between the irregular metal and the struck design matters more than a vague rough appearance. A later scrape cuts across a design that was already present.
Some blank defects relate to weak alloy layers. Each coin still needs its own physical explanation.
Estimated Value
Estimate $75–$1,000 for a confirmed defective-blank Peace dollar, with the normal coin’s condition included. Clear evidence that the irregularity predates striking supports an error premium.
As a nearby-year metal-flaw comparison, a 1923 cracked-planchet dollar graded PCGS MS64 brought $432 in March 2023. A crack is a specific defect, so its price cannot identify an unexplained rough patch.
The AU58 Details description signals a separate condition issue. Compare original surfaces and defect severity before selecting a price within the range.
How to Identify
Examine how letters or portrait detail meet the irregular area. The useful question is whether the strike formed around an existing flaw or whether damage removed a finished design.
Follow any design that continues onto the abnormal surface with a magnifier. Look for cut edges, scraping, or corrosion that could account for the appearance after production.
If the defect reaches the edge, photograph the face and edge together. Measurements of a loose coin can help: an ordinary example starts near 26.73 grams and 38.1 millimeters.
Those normal dimensions alone cannot prove a blank flaw. Have the struck-design boundary examined before deciding what specific original metal problem best explains it.
4. 1922 Peace Dollar Crack through the Metal
A narrow opening extending into the dollar can be a crack in the blank itself. Unlike a raised die-crack line, this defect separates the coin’s metal.
A dealer gallery records a quarter-inch cracked blank. A separate auction listing describes a PCGS MS62 example with a quarter-inch crack at five-thirty.
The size describes those examples rather than every cracked dollar. An opening may begin in weak metal and become more visible during striking.
Later bending, cutting, or forcing can also split a coin. The fracture surface and its connection with the design must support an original production defect.
Estimated Value
The quarter-inch cracked example graded PCGS MS62 sold for $180 in July 2021. Estimate $100–$1,200 for authenticated cracked blanks, from modest openings to more dramatic defects.
A cleanly visible original fracture can attract interest, but its severity does not automatically outweigh poor surfaces. Wear and later damage affect the whole coin’s price.
An actual opening is essential to this estimate. A raised crack copied from a broken stamping tool belongs to a different error category.
How to Identify
Look directly at the edge where the suspected fracture begins. A physical opening separates a cracked blank from a raised line copied from a damaged tool.
Trace that opening onto the face under magnification, leaving the coin still. Never flex it to test whether the crack moves.
The auction example’s five-thirty position applies to that specimen, while the dealer’s quarter-inch description does not supply a direction.
Inspect both faces for a bend or blow that could have forced the metal apart later. A straight saw cut or fresh tool tracks require a different explanation.
Check the fracture walls and adjoining struck detail together so the opening can be judged as an original metal flaw.
5. 1922 Peace Dollar Clipped Edges
A bite out of the edge can originate when the blank-cutting punch overlaps an earlier hole in the metal strip. The incomplete disc then receives the dollar design.
Philadelphia examples include small clips described around one or two o’clock. Another PCGS AU58 example has a two-percent clip, without a position supplied by that description.
Nearby rim or lettering can weaken as metal moves toward the missing area during striking. The gap itself is not necessarily a sharp finished cut.
An edge notch made later can imitate the outline. The surface and adjoining design are needed to establish a true clip.
Estimated Value
Estimate $150–$1,500 for authenticated clipped Peace dollars, including the value of the full coin. Small gaps and circulated surfaces generally point toward the lower portion.
A clearly shaped clip with natural borders has more appeal than an ambiguous edge flaw. The two-percent example should be compared with other small clips, not dramatic missing halves.
This range uses silver-dollar clipping comparisons and condition differences. A gouged, sawed, or filed edge does not gain the same premium simply because metal is missing.
How to Identify
Locate the gap on a whole-coin view, then inspect the rim immediately to each side. Check whether its shape and nearby lettering weaken naturally toward the absent metal.
For the small upper-edge examples, keep their separate one- or two-o’clock positions straight. Do not assign either location to the independently reported two-percent coin without its photograph.
Look along the inner wall for saw lines, sharp burrs, or filing. Old damage can darken, so matching color is only a small part of the assessment.
A loose clipped dollar should weigh below the normal 26.73 grams, but cutting has the same effect. Compare the gap wall with the adjoining struck design before treating the missing metal as an original clip.
6. 1922 Peace Dollar Doubled Dates and Back Details
Extra raised edges on the date or eagle-side design can be copied from a doubled stamping tool. The coin itself does not need a second strike to show those details.
Philadelphia date doubling appears along the digits’ lower-right sides. Flat doubling on the left can be a separate effect from movement during striking.
Philadelphia back patterns affect olive leaves, eagle details, lettering, or selected rays. Denver has a separate tripled-leaf variety.
These should be compared by mint and location. Some Philadelphia coins also carry the Moustache crack, so different features can occur together without representing separate coins.
Estimated Value
Estimate $75–$2,000 for identified doubled-date or repeated-back-design examples in commonly collected conditions. Clear separation and a recognized pattern support more interest than a thick-looking letter.
For comparison from a different year, a 1926-S VAM-5 doubled-back dollar graded AU58 has a PCGS-recorded $750 April 2019 sale. Its design pattern is not the 1922 Denver or Philadelphia variety.
The whole coin’s mint, preservation, and any additional named feature remain part of the price. Later scratches do not qualify as doubling.
How to Identify
Begin on the lower-right sides of the date digits for the Philadelphia front variety. Compare the extra raised outlines there before examining flatter ledges that may appear on the left.
For a back variety, select the correct mint first. Philadelphia examples need comparisons around the olive leaves, eagle’s leg or claws, ONE, DO, and the appropriate neighboring rays.
The Denver tripled-leaf coin needs its own close image. Do not transfer every Philadelphia doubled location to that example.
Change the lighting if reflections make an outline appear or disappear. Match repeated raised details in several listed locations, rather than assigning a variety from one flat shelf beside a numeral.
7. 1922 Peace Dollar Moustache and Other Broken-Tool Features
A raised crack beneath Liberty’s nose can resemble a moustache on the Philadelphia VAM-12A variety. It is metal copied from a damaged stamping tool, not hair added to the design.
A crack near the base of the crown helps with comparison. The raised feature can become thicker as the tool deteriorates.
Denver dollars have different reported breaks around the hair bun and LIBERTY’s R, T, or Y. Some involve a broken tool section that moved but remained in place.
The mint and exact pattern matter. A 1923 “Whisker” coin is not the same variety as the 1922 Philadelphia Moustache.
Estimated Value
A Moustache example graded MS64 has a PCGS-recorded $1,438 August 2011 auction result. Estimate $75–$2,500 across identifiable 1922 cracks and broken-tool varieties.
The stronger portion of the range suits a clear named feature and attractive surfaces. A tiny ordinary crack may add little to the coin’s normal value.
Denver break patterns need their own comparisons rather than the Philadelphia Moustache price alone. The amount values the complete coin, including its grade and any accompanying variety features.
How to Identify
Inspect the space between Liberty’s nose and upper lip before searching the rest of the face. The Philadelphia Moustache feature should stand above the surface in the documented position.
Compare the supporting crack near the crown base. A scratched line below the nose or a speck of attached material cannot establish VAM-12A.
On a Denver coin, move to its specific hair-bun or LIBERTY pattern instead. A retained broken tool section can alter a larger area than a simple thin crack.
Check raised edges under side lighting, keeping nearby letters in the photograph. Confirm the moustache-shaped raised crack and supporting crown feature together when identifying the Philadelphia variety.
8. 1922 Peace Dollar Struck-Through Impressions
A soft blank area or shaped depression can form when material blocks contact between the tool and coin. The object’s size and shape influence the resulting struck-through error.
One 1922 auction example has extensive weakness on both faces. Other reports include a line across the back below DOLLAR and a metal-piece impression affecting the date’s final 22.
Those are separate coins with different appearances. A wire-like line cannot explain every broad weak area.
Normal wear smooths exposed high points, while an obstruction can interrupt selected design details. Later gouges can also remove detail, making the depression’s border important.
Estimated Value
A 1922 example with significant struck-through areas on both faces sold for $552 in November 2024, as reported by Coin World. Estimate $75–$3,000 across minor through major authenticated examples.
Clear shaped impressions may attract more interest than a vague soft patch. The coin’s surface preservation also affects the total.
Do not value separate line, metal-piece, and broad-obstruction examples as though they were one especially dramatic coin. Each needs its own comparison.
How to Identify
Decide whether you are examining a narrow line, a shaped depression, or a broad weak area. That first distinction determines which reported example is useful.
For the back-line report, inspect below DOLLAR and compare the impression with the normal rays nearby. For the date example, study the last two digits and the surrounding undamaged metal.
Across broad weak areas, compare protected recesses and high points to distinguish an obstruction from circulation wear. Check both faces of the coin rather than assuming only the front was affected.
Look for sharp cutting tracks or displaced metal around a later gouge. Trace the original boundary of the blocked design before naming the material that might have caused it.
9. 1922 Peace Dollar Stepped Edge from a Partial Collar
The edge can have a step when only part of the blank sits inside the collar during striking. The collar is the ring that controls the dollar’s width and forms its edge grooves.
Metal held inside the ring behaves differently from the portion above it, which can spread outward. That difference creates the partial-collar appearance.
A Philadelphia NGC AU58 example provides a recorded comparison. Its description does not set a required height or tilt for every such coin.
A rim flattened by a holder or a later blow can look unusual too. The entire edge profile needs examination.
Estimated Value
The recorded Philadelphia NGC AU58 coin sold for $720 in March 2021. Estimate $300–$3,000 for authenticated partial-collar Peace dollars with clear original edge structure.
A pronounced step and preserved grooves make the error easier to see. Faint unevenness or heavy rim damage reduces the usefulness of the comparison.
This price range includes the whole coin rather than a fixed amount per millimeter of expansion. An ordinary dollar with a rolled or ground edge belongs outside it.
How to Identify
View the edge from the side before studying either face. A ledge can separate normally grooved metal from the part that spread outside the collar.
Turn the coin slowly and photograph how that transition changes around the circumference. A holder may hide part of the edge, limiting what a photograph can establish.
Compare the adjoining rim for dents or signs that the coin was mounted in jewelry. Later pressure can distort the edge without producing a partial-collar strike.
A loose example can be measured in several directions against the normal 38.1-millimeter width.
Follow the original grooves into the expanded portion, checking for a natural step rather than compressed or ground metal.
10. 1922 Peace Dollar Broadstrike
An oversized rim area can surround a complete design when the collar fails to contain the metal during striking. The resulting coin is called a broadstrike.
San Francisco examples are recorded at PCGS AU55 and NGC AU58. Those grades belong to their separate source examples and should not be combined.
The metal spreads beyond the usual dollar boundary, while the design remains on the coin. It can be unevenly centered without becoming an off-center strike.
A later blow can also flatten and widen a dollar. The naturally struck design and expanded edge must fit the same original event.
Estimated Value
An estimated $2,500–$10,000 applies to an authenticated 1922-S broadstrike. Its expanded original border and remaining condition determine where it falls within that range.
A different-year Peace-dollar broadstrike graded NGC AU58 brought $7,762.50 in January 2009. That coin was dated 1921 and used the earlier higher-relief design.
The comparison shows the scale of a scarce silver-dollar broadstrike, not an exact price for either recorded 1922-S specimen. Later flattening has a different effect on value.
How to Identify
A broadstrike must preserve the complete design, so inspect the outer words and date on both faces before measuring anything. If design falls beyond the disc, investigate an off-center strike instead of relying on the coin’s oversized appearance.
For a loose coin, record its width in several directions with calipers and compare it with the normal 38.1-millimeter diameter. Inspect the expanded edge beside those measurements for natural metal spreading, rather than grinding that merely removes the usual grooves.
Normal weight is 26.73 grams, but later flattening can leave that weight unchanged while crushing design detail. Compare the outward-spread border with the preserved struck design to establish that expansion occurred during the original strike.
11. 1922 Peace Dollar Off-Center Strike
A displaced design beside an unstruck crescent shows that the blank was not properly positioned beneath the tools. Part of the design missed the metal entirely.
Both faces should reflect the same misplaced disc. A sideways tool shift affecting only one face requires a different explanation.
A documented 1922-S example was struck fifteen percent off center and graded PCGS MS65. Other reported 1922 examples must be judged by their own visible displacement.
The surviving date and mintmark help establish identity. Percentage claims taken from another coin do not substitute for measuring and comparing the actual specimen.
Estimated Value
The 1922-S fifteen-percent off-center dollar brought $32,200 at the 2003 ANA auction, reported by PCGS. Estimate $3,000–$35,000 for authenticated examples with clear displacement.
The historical result belongs to a well-preserved MS65 coin. Worn surfaces, cleaning, and a less visible error can place another specimen much lower.
A readable date and natural unstruck crescent increase the usefulness of a comparison. An uneven border without lost design should not receive this major-error range.
How to Identify
Compare both faces with the unstruck crescent kept in the same physical position. The portrait and eagle designs should be displaced together relative to that metal.
Find the date and any surviving mintmark next. The documented fifteen-percent coin is San Francisco; a generic 1922 report should not automatically become that specific example.
Inspect the line where the struck surface ends. It should meet untouched blank metal rather than a filed groove, glued extension, or later flattened patch.
An enlarged coin with all design present can be a broadstrike instead. Confirm that design is actually lost beyond the edge while corresponding blank metal remains on both faces.
12. 1922 Peace Dollar Repeated Strikes and Flipover Claims
A second strike after rotation can place an earlier mouth impression within Liberty’s neck. A Philadelphia PCGS MS64 example was cataloged with a ninety-degree clockwise turn between strikes.
The eagle’s tail and legs also preserve overlapping detail. The coin remained within the collar rather than developing a large displaced crescent.
A separate San Francisco owner described apparent PEACE lettering on the front and date or portrait traces on the back. Its ordinary NGC MS65 grade does not confirm the proposed flipover error.
A genuine flipover needs opposite-face designs on each side. Faint imagined letters or clash marks are insufficient.
Estimated Value
For authenticated repeated strikes, estimate $8,000–$40,000, with the upper portion reserved for exceptionally clear combinations. A confirmed flipover may be estimated within $15,000–$40,000.
As a different-year comparison, a double-struck 1921 Peace dollar with a back scratch sold for $8,400 in November 2024. Its ten-degree rotation and damaged surface differ from the 1922 Philadelphia coin.
The San Francisco claim does not receive a confirmed-error price merely because the holder grades the ordinary coin MS65. Its repeated designs must first be authenticated.
How to Identify
Read the holder description before interpreting the San Francisco claim: an ordinary MS65 grade does not authenticate a second strike.
The Philadelphia example has a different starting point. Find the earlier mouth impression within Liberty’s neck and the matching rotated detail at the eagle’s tail and legs.
Those remnants must fit the same quarter-turn movement on both faces. Isolated doubled letters cannot establish that sequence.
For a flipover, recognizable back design must remain on the front, with front design on the back. Trace several connected details rather than naming a faint mark PEACE.
Have those opposite-face design relationships checked by an error specialist before assigning a confirmed flipover value.
Conclusion
A Peace dollar’s unusual feature must explain how the coin was made. Raised tool cracks, peeling metal, and repeated designs tell different stories.
The estimated $60–$40,000 range includes both modest varieties and major authenticated errors. The highest amounts require clear physical evidence, not an imaginative reading of faint marks.
Compare the correct mint and both faces, keep loose metal intact, and leave original surfaces untouched while identifying the error.